Flavor of the Neighborhood: Squirrel Hill Dining Guide
In Squirrel Hill, every meal tells a story. Known as one of Pittsburgh’s most diverse culinary landscapes, this neighborhood allows you to travel from a James Beard-recognized kitchen in Sichuan to a 100-year-old Jewish bakery all within a single afternoon. Whether you're here for the legendary "Pizza War" or seeking the city's best Kosher eats, Squirrel Hill is a walker’s paradise for food lovers.
The Great Pizza Debate: Mineo’s vs. Aiello’s
You haven't truly visited Squirrel Hill until you’ve taken a side in the city's most famous food rivalry. On Murray Avenue, two legendary parlors have sat just a block apart for generations, each claiming the title of Pittsburgh's best slice.
Mineo’s Pizza House | 2128 Murray Ave.
A local institution since 1958. Mineo’s is famous for its "more is more" philosophy. Expect a thick, golden layer of hand-grated Italian cheese and a rich, traditional sauce.
Aiello’s Pizza | 2112 Murray Ave.
Founded by a former Mineo’s employee who struck out on his own, Aiello’s focuses on a slightly crispier, thinner crust and a signature spice blend in the sauce that has won over a fiercely loyal following.
The Visitor Challenge: Grab a slice from both and do a side-by-side taste test at one of the neighborhood's many public benches
A Taste of Tradition: Pittsburgh’s Kosher Capital
As the historic heart of the city’s Jewish community, Squirrel Hill offers the most authentic Kosher dining experience in the region. This isn't just about the food; it's about a rich heritage of craft, community, and flavors that have been perfected over generations.
Pigeon Bagels | 5613 Hobart St.
A modern favorite that has quickly become a neighborhood institution. Known for their certified Kosher, boiled-and-baked bagels, this cozy spot often has a line stretching down Hobart Street, but trust the locals, it is well worth the wait. Whether you’re grabbing a "classic lox" or their famous vegan carrot lox, every bite captures the perfect balance of a crispy crust and a chewy center.
The Bagel Factory | 5885 Forbes Ave.
A longtime neighborhood staple located right in the middle of the Forbes Avenue bustle. For years, this has been the go-to spot for a quick morning "schmear" or a massive catering spread. With its outdoor seating and classic deli feel, it’s a perfect place to enjoy a fresh bagel while watching the neighborhood wake up.
Bunny Bakes | 1926 Murray Ave.
More than just a bakery, this beloved spot is a testament to the community's inclusive spirit. Run by the Friendship Circle, Bunny Bakes offers high-quality Kosher treats like their signature Honey Bunny Latte and fresh-baked rugelach with a mission of providing meaningful employment and training for individuals of all abilities.
Murray Avenue Grill | 1720 Murray Ave.
If you’re looking for that classic, "everyone-knows-your-name" deli atmosphere, this is your place. It serves as a warm, welcoming hub for locals to catch up over traditional favorites. From hearty soups to signature sandwiches, it offers a comfortable, no-frills experience that feels like a big neighborhood hug.
Specialty Markets | various locations along Forbes & Murray
To truly eat like a local, you have to shop like one. Explore the specialized markets along Forbes Avenue, such as the Squirrel Hill Market, to find imported Israeli goods, jars of authentic pickles, and tradition-rich deli meats. On Friday mornings, you’ll see the neighborhood come alive as residents stop in to pick up fresh, braided Challah for the upcoming Sabbath.
Authentic Asian Cuisine & Shopping
Squirrel Hill boasts the largest concentration of Asian restaurants in Pittsburgh, offering everything from street food to fine dining.
Cheng Du Gourmet | 5840 Forward Ave.
Don’t let the unassuming exterior fool you, this is a true pilgrimage site for lovers of authentic Sichuan spice. Led by five-time James Beard semifinalist Chef Wei Zhu, Chengdu Gourmet serves up the kind of bold, complex heat that draws food critics from across the country. For the full experience, ask for the traditional menu to discover neighborhood legends like the Chongqing Chicken (crispy diced chicken buried in a mountain of dried red peppers) or the fragrant, numbing Cumin Lamb. It is an intoxicating masterclass in the art of the Sichuan peppercorn.
Everyday Noodles | 5875 Forbes Ave.
Walking into Everyday Noodles feels like stepping into a live theater performance. Through a massive display window, you can watch master chefs expertly slam, twist, and stretch dough into hundreds of delicate strands in a matter of seconds. While the hand-pulled noodles are the namesake, the Pork Soup Dumplings (Xiao Long Bao) are a local obsession, each one a perfectly balanced, paper-thin wrapper holding a rich, soul-warming broth. It’s a bright, bustling spot that captures the energetic spirit of the neighborhood.
Taiwanese Bistro Cafe 33 | 1711 Shady Ave.
Tucked away on Shady Avenue, this local gem feels more like a welcoming home than a restaurant. It’s the city's go-to spot for authentic Taiwanese xiaochi (small eats) and comfort food. Locals rave about the Mini Soup Dumplings and the Three-Cup Chicken with basil and garlic, which arrives at your table sizzling in a traditional stone hot pot. It’s the perfect place for a cozy, unpretentious meal that feels like a well-kept neighborhood secret.
Amazing Dumplings | 5882 Forbes Ave.
Just as the name suggests, this spot is a masterclass in Northern Chinese comfort food. Every morning, the staff hand-makes colorful, seasonal dumplings that range from traditional pork and leek to creative options like Ma Po Tofu or even heart-shaped specials. Beyond the dumplings, don’t miss their Biangbiang noodles, thick, wide, hand-pulled ribbons served with savory chili oil and aromatic spices that offer the perfect "chew."
The Coffee & Tea Trail: Squirrel Hill’s Cozy Hubs
Squirrel Hill’s coffee and tea scene is the perfect reflection of the neighborhood: a mix of local heritage, global inspiration, and student-friendly energy. Whether you need a quiet corner for your laptop or a vibrant spot for a "catch-up" with friends, you’ll find your perfect brew at these local favorites.
Commonplace Coffee | 5827 Forbes Ave.
A true local favorite right in the heart of the action. Known for roasting their own beans and providing a warm, welcoming space, it’s a go-to for serious coffee lovers and students alike looking for a high-quality, handcrafted cup.
Afters Cafe | 1708 Murray Ave.
Located on Murray Avenue, this spot is perfect for "after-work" or "after-class" vibes. They serve specialty coffee and a unique selection of teas, including Lebanese Tea (a wildflower and herb blend) and Black Mint Tea, in a modern and relaxed atmosphere.
61C Cafe | 1839 Murray Ave.
A quintessential neighborhood coffee house named after the bus route that runs right past its door. It’s cozy, unpretentious, and always buzzing with locals—a perfect spot to grab a seat and soak in the authentic Squirrel Hill energy.
The Bubble Tea District | Various locations along Forbes & Murray
For a deeper dive into tea culture, explore the neighborhood's numerous specialized shops. From authentic Taiwanese Bubble Tea at places like Kung Fu Tea (5841 Forbes Ave) or T-Swirl Crepe (5808 Forbes Ave) which pairs tea with Instagram-worthy Japanese-style crepes to traditional matcha, there is a tea for every mood.
