Pittsburgh's Fish Fry-Days

Pittsburgh's Fish Fry-Days

Lent is here, which means that it's time for Fish Fry-days at restaurants, churches and fire halls across the city!

It’s Fish Fry-days season and there are lots of places around Pittsburgh to get a great fish sandwich. If you're not sure why fish on Friday is a thing, let me back up a bit. Lent (March 2 - April 14), is a religious observance by many Christian denominations that covers a period of approximately six weeks before Easter Sunday. During all of the Fridays of Lent, Catholics over the age of 14 abstain from meat and from foods made with meat. 

North

North Park Lounge, North Hills

The hook here is the NPL 12oz Giant Fish Sandwich comes from the secret beer batter that the fish is dipped in and then fried to a golden brown

Kretzler’s Tavern, North Hills

Family-owned restaurant where everything is made from fresh, local ingredients and prepared daily. Known for their Famous Fish Sandwich.

Riverview United Presbyterian Church, North Shore

Serves all your favorite fish fry goodies! Riverview hand-batters their haddock, and all french fries are freshly cut. Their menu of classic side dishes include: haluski, mac and cheese, pickle chips, spicy hot cheese balls, clam chowder, and more.

Share Your Story On Social #LovePGH

South

The Pub Chip Shop, South Side

The fish and chips is excellent. Their hand battered haddock is moist, flaky and creamy. It’s spiced just right and the texture is not greasy at all. 

Community Kitchen Pittsburgh, Hazelwood

Hand-battered fish along with many sides, homemade by culinary trainees, including pierogies, mac & cheese, clam chowder and cole slaw. Online ordering available. Credit cards accepted.

St. Joan of Arc Church, South Park

Takeout only offering various fried and baked options including fried or baked fish, crab cakes, shrimp dinner, mac & cheese, peirogies, desserts and more! 

Oak Hill Post, Brookline

Newly opened in 2020, Oak Hill Post is a casual neighborhood eatery offering delicious breakfast and specialty sandwiches. Their cornflake breaded Barramundi fish filet on a house made buttermilk biscuit is not to be missed!

East

Big Jim’s Restaurant & Bar, Greenfield

An off-the-beaten-path bar that’s not fancy but their food is great. Big portions and good service. They were featured on Food Network’s Diners Drive-Ins and Dives. The atmosphere and location are part of the whole experience. Takeout only.

Swissvale Fire Department, Swissvale

Beer-battered fish sandwich is tasty and hearty. The mac & cheese is good and the haluski usually sells out quickly so get there early.

Stinky’s, Lawrenceville

Giant fish sandwich with great fries. It gets crowded on Fridays during Lent so go early or later in the evening.

E-Town Bar and Grill, Etna

Tucked into a stretch of row houses along Butler Street, E-Town has a great beer selection and terrific food, including flavorful fish sandwiches. The place is hopping on Friday nights and the restaurant isn’t that big so get there early.

The Grant Bar & Lounge, Millvale

Grant’s has long been known for their fish sandwiches. The generous size leaves plenty to share (if you want to!) Pair it with their off-the-chart onion rings and you won’t be hungry again for a while.

West

Elly's, Carnegie

Jumbo fried fish sandwich AND jumbo fried fish - need we say more? If you get the jumbo it will feed two people. Enjoy it with french fries and cole slaw. 

St. Margaret of Scotland, Green Tree 

They offer a fish trio dinner with fried fish, shrimp and a crab cake! Other menu options include pierogies, soups, haluski and more. Take out only! 

Downtown

The Original Oyster House, Downtown

This old-school fish house & tavern (since 1870) located in historic Market Square, offers fresh seafood platters. The cod has a delicate flavor with just the right amount of spices and he onion rings are perfection!

Epiphany Catholic Church, Uptown

The kitchen is in the lower level. They serve lots of scrumptious sides. Service is quick. You can call ahead and order and pick up. The pierogies are very good and if you’re not too full try the New England clam chowder. Takeout only.

Strip District

Robert Wholey & Co., Inc., Strip District

It’s the building with the big fish on the side! Fish of every kind imaginable including incredible melt-in-your-mouth, buttery fish sandwiches. Try the Saintly Scallop Po’boy (breaded scallops topped with chipotle remoulade) or the Wholey Holy Moley (Icelandic cod sandwich).

Penn Avenue Fish Company, Strip District

Super casual, loft-like, vibrant restaurant for sampling sushi and daily catches. It’s a great place to get fresh and delicious fish.

Photo Credit: Wholey's Facebook Page

There are plenty more options in the greater Pittsburgh area to grab some fish over the next few months. If you're a fan of the church fish frys, check out this guide to Parish Fish Frys. The Pittsburgh Post Gazette also has a great guide you can follow, and there's even an interactive map of fish frys to check out! So many options, so much fish to try!